She’ll Never See It Coming: Catalina Island Surprise Proposal Guide from SoCal
Thinking about proposing but want to do it in a way that feels adventurous, cinematic, and completely unexpected? Catalina Island is the ultimate hidden gem for couples in Southern California planning a surprise proposal. Just an hour off the coast from San Diego or Orange County, this island has it all: bike rides along scenic coastal roads, kayaking in turquoise coves, epic bison expeditions, romantic beachfront restaurants, and golden hour views that rival Italy.
In this guide, we break down two foolproof itineraries—one for a romantic day trip and another for an overnight getaway—plus share exactly how to pull off the surprise without raising suspicion. As proposal photographers, we specialize in moments like these, and our Undercover “Yes” Package was designed to help you stay fully in the moment while we blend in as tourists, documenting it all. From ferry rides to the big question, this is your play-by-play for the perfect Catalina Island engagement—no stress, no stiff poses, just real emotion and a story you’ll never stop telling.
Cover Image Courtesy of Anthony Mucci
Planning a surprise proposal from San Diego or Orange County and want it to feel cinematic, private, and unforgettable? Look no further than Catalina Island.
Just about an hour away by ferry, Catalina offers the perfect blend of outdoor adventure and coastal charm for couples looking to turn “Will you marry me?” into a real-life love story. From kayaking coves to biking coastal trails, and from bison safaris to sunset beaches, this island sets the scene for one of the most breathtaking engagement experiences in all of Southern California.
And the best part? You can easily reach it from Dana Point, Long Beach, or San Pedro, making it ideal whether you're coming from San Diego, Orange County, or Los Angeles. Most ferries land in Avalon, a romantic Mediterranean-style town where you can plan your entire day—from the coffee run to the proposal moment.
As professional proposal photographers, we’ve helped couples pull off emotional, candid, and stunning proposals all across SoCal. Here’s how to make Catalina Island the backdrop of your engagement story—plus insider photography tips to make sure every shot is picture-perfect.
Whether you're planning a proposal, an event, or a creative shoot and just want to talk it through—we’re here for it. Book a free consultation and let's bring your vision to life together.
👉 Book a Free Consultation
Where to Catch the Ferry
You can book your ride through Catalina Express from three main departure points:
Dana Point – Best for couples coming from San Diego or South Orange County
Long Beach – Convenient with frequent departures and parking
San Pedro – Great for LA-based travelers
Most ferries take about 1 hour and land in Avalon, the ideal town for proposals, photography, dining, and adventures.
Surprise Proposal Itinerary: Catalina Day Trip (Return Same Day)
For couples who want a sunrise start, island adventure, and sunset engagement—all in one day.
6:30 AM – Sunrise Coffee & Ferry Ride
Grab coffee from Better Buzz in Encinitas or Hidden House Coffee in San Juan Capistrano. Catch the first ferry from Dana Point or Long Beach.
📸 Photo Tip: Ask your photographer to meet you at the ferry (or already be on the boat) and discreetly document this “normal morning” start for your proposal story album.
8:00 AM – Arrive in Avalon & Explore
Once you arrive, rent bikes at Brown’s Bikes to cruise along the shoreline or explore the island’s charming town streets.
📸 Photo Tip: These are great candid moments. Capture wind-in-your-hair bike shots along the waterfront. Ask your photographer to bike behind you or shoot from afar.
10:00 AM – Choose Your Adventure
Kayak through clear turquoise coves
Book a Bison Expedition Tour through Catalina’s rugged interior
Hike to Wrigley Memorial & Botanical Garden for cliffside views
📸 Photo Tip: Use natural light to your advantage. Mornings offer soft, directional light—ideal for shooting landscapes, ocean reflections, and authentic action moments.
1:00 PM – Beachfront Lunch
Reserve a spot at Descanso Beach Club for tropical cocktails and upscale beach eats.
📸 Photo Tip: If you're proposing after lunch, your photographer can grab lifestyle photos of you two to build the visual story leading into the big moment.
3:00 PM – The Proposal
Take a “casual walk” up to Buena Vista Point or along the Garden to Sky Trail. The scenery is stunning, with panoramic views of the ocean, cliffs, and Catalina below.
📸 Photo Tip: Coordinate your location and timing with the photographer. Golden hour begins to soften the light, and overhead shadows fade. Go for a wide shot of the landscape just before you propose—then get close-ups after the moment.
3:30 PM – Engagement Portraits
Capture the post-“yes” glow. Walk through Avalon’s streets, stop by pastel-colored walls, floral-covered paths, and the harbor pier for editorial-style portraits.
5:00 PM – Ferry Home
Pop champagne (or sparkling water) on the ferry ride home as newly engaged fiancés.
Surprise Proposal Itinerary: Catalina Overnight Escape
For couples who want to take their time, soak in the moment, and wake up engaged.
Day 1
10:00 AM – Ferry to Avalon
Catch a late-morning ferry from Long Beach or Dana Point and enjoy a relaxed journey.
11:30 AM – Check-In & Drop Bags
Romantic hotels worth booking:
Mt. Ada – Iconic mansion-turned-boutique hotel overlooking Avalon
Aurora Hotel – Sleek, modern design with rooftop views
Hotel Atwater – Classic Catalina charm near everything
📸 Photo Tip: Ask for a balcony room or rooftop access for a golden hour silhouette photo later.
1:00 PM – Lunch by the Harbor
Head to Bluewater Grill or try fresh seafood tacos at Lloyd's for something casual.
3:00 PM – Explore or Relax
Options:
Book a Zip Line Eco Tour
Rent a golf cart and scout your proposal location
Book a couples massage at Island Spa Catalina
📸 Photo Tip: If you're scoping out your proposal location, this is a great time for your photographer to test angles and light levels without raising suspicion.
6:00 PM – Surprise Proposal at Sunset
Walk your partner to a quiet lookout or private cove. A pre-planned cue (like “let’s take a selfie”) triggers the photographer to begin shooting.
📸 Photo Tip: We recommend backlighting the proposal moment during golden hour to create a dreamy glow. Avoid direct harsh sunlight on faces—let nature set the mood.
6:30 PM – Dinner to Celebrate
Celebrate the engagement at Avalon Grille or Maggie’s Blue Rose with wine, dessert, and lots of smiles.
Day 2
9:00 AM – Island Morning Stroll
Start the day at Catalina Coffee & Cookie Co. with coffee and a pastry. Stroll through town, stop at the beach, and just be.
12:00 PM – Ferry Home
Ride back with zero pressure, a full heart, and a camera roll full of joy.
The Undercover Proposal Package: We’re In On the Surprise
Want your Catalina Island proposal to feel spontaneous and cinematic—with zero stress or suspicion? Our Undercover “Yes” Surprise Proposal Package is designed for exactly this moment.
Here’s how it works:
We blend in as tourists from the very start—on the ferry ride, during lunch, or while you explore the island.
We’ll discreetly document the entire lead-up so nothing feels staged or forced.
When the moment is right, you drop to one knee—and we’re already in position to capture it all.
After the “YES,” we shift into engagement portraits so you walk away with an entire visual story.
This package is perfect for Catalina Island because it allows you to enjoy the adventure without worrying about logistics or giving away the surprise. We’ve pulled off dozens of proposals where the partner had no idea until the exact second it happened—and we’re ready to do the same for you.
👉 See what's included in the Undercover “Yes” Proposal Package
Want Help Planning the Perfect Surprise Proposal?
We’re a husband-and-wife photography team based in SoCal who specialize in capturing authentic, emotional surprise proposals from San Diego to Orange County and beyond—including full-day adventures to Catalina Island.
✔️ Hidden photographer
✔️ Timeline support
✔️ Location planning
✔️ Sneak peeks within 48 hours
👉 Book a free consultation here
📲 Or follow our journey on Instagram: @lastminutephotoshoot
Your proposal deserves more than a snapshot. Let’s make it unforgettable.